Software Process Assessment and Improvement Using Multicriteria Decision Aiding - Constructivist

Leonardo Ensslin, Luiz Carlos Mesquita Scheid, Sandra Rolim Ensslin, Rogerio Tadeu de Oliveira Lacerda


Software process improvement and software process assessment have received special attention since the 1980s. Some models have been created, but these models rest on a normative approach, where the decision-maker’s participation in a software organization is limited to understanding which process is more relevant to each organization. The proposal of this work is to present the MCDA-C as a constructivist methodology for software process improvement and assessment. The methodology makes it possible to visualize the criteria that must be taken into account according to the decision-makers’ values in the process improvement actions, making it possible to rank actions in the light of specific organizational needs. This process helped the manager of the company studied to focus on and prioritize process improvement actions. This paper offers an empirical understanding of the application of performance evaluation to software process improvement and identifies complementary tools to the normative models presented today.


software process assessment ; software process improvement ; decision ; performance measurement ; CMMI ; SPICE

Full Text:



BARTHÉLEMY, J.; R. BISDORFF, R., e; COPPIN, G. Human centered processes and decision support systems, European Journal of Operational Research, Volume 136, No. 2, Pag.: 233-252, 2002.

CMMI V1.1 – SCAMPI V1.1 – Class A Appraisal Results. Carnegie Mellon University. Software Engineering Institute., 2004.

CMMI-SE/SW CONTINUOUS REPRESENTATION. CMMI for Systems Engineering/Software Engineering/Integrated Product and Process Development, Version 1.02, Continuous Representation., 2002.

CMMI-SE/SW STAGED REPRESENTATION. CMMI for Systems Engineering/Software Engineering/Integrated Product and Process Development, Version 1.02, Staged Representation., 2002.

ENSSLIN, L.; NETO G.; ZANELLA I.; NORONHA, S. Apoio à Decisão: Metodologias para Estruturação de Problemas e Avaliação Multicritério de Alternativas. INSULAR, LabMCDA; Florianópolis- SC; 2002.

ISO/IEC15504-1: Information Technology – Software Process Assessment Part 1: Concepts and Introductory Guide. ISO/IEC JTC1/SC7 N1592.6, 1996.

ISO/IEC15504-2: Information Technology – Software Process Assessment Part 2: A Reference Model For Processes And Process Capability. ISO/IEC JTC1/SC7 N1594, 1996.

ISO/IEC15504-3: Information Technology – Software Process Assessment Part 3: Rating Processes. ISO/IEC JTC1/SC7 N1594, 1996.

LEE, H.; JUNG, H.; CHUNG, C.; LEE, J.; LEE, K.; JEONG, H. Analysis of interrater agreement in ISO/IEC 15504-based software process assessment. Quality Software, 2001. Proceedings.Second Asia-Pacific Conference on, Vol., Iss., Pages:341-348, 2001.

NIAZI, M.; WILSON, D.; ZOWGHI, D. A maturity model for the implementation of software process improvement: an empirical study. The Journal of Systems and Software, Vol. 74, Pag.: 155-172, 2003

PITTERMAN, B. Telcordia technologies: the journey to high maturity. IEEE Software (July–August), 89–96, 2000.

KUILBOER, J.; ASHRAFI, N. Software process and product improvement: an empirical assessment, Information and Software Technology, Volume 42, Issue 1, Pages 27-34, 2000.

RAINER, A. e HALL, T. Key success factors for implementing software process improvement: a maturity-based analysis. Journal of Systems and Software, Vol. 62, No. 2, Pag.: 71-84., 2002.

SAIEDIAN, H.; MCCLANAHAN, L. A study of two frameworks for quality software process. Symposium on Applied Computing, Nashville, Tennessee, Estados Unidos, Pag.: 434 – 439, 1995.

SHEARD, S.; ROEDLER G. Interpreting continuous-view capability models for higher levels of maturity. Systems Engineering Copyright © 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Vol. 2, No. 1, Pag.: 15-31, 1999.

WANG, Y.; COURT, I.; ROSS, M.; STAPLES, G.; KING, G. Towards a Software Process Reference Model (SPRM), Proceedings of International Conference on Sofrware Process Improvement (SPI’96), Brighton, 1996

WANG, Y., KING, G., DORLING, A., PATEL, D., COURT, I., STAPLES, G. ROSS, M., A Worldwide Survey of Base Process Activities Towards Software Engineering Process Excellence, IEEE, 1998.

Licensed under